A few days ago I launched a new discussion forum for anyone interested in films, movies and cinema...
I'd organised a logo from somewhere, but they hadn't delivered...
Now I've got to choose between two logos and I can't make up my mind.
I like them both!
Which of them is more suitable?
Option 1:
Option 2:
Option 2:

Michele,
Both pretty good. Liking the forum too, must get around to registering...
ps: did you simpsonize yourself - go on, post the result!
Glad you like the forum :)
I haven't simponised myself yet - I might do when I get a spare moment, though I may not share the results!
I would go with #1 for the film image but overlay with the logo and sub-tag of #2. #2 easier to read, but #1 more powerful imagery.
All IMHO only :)
n. 2 :)
Number 2. Definitely. Number 1 has that reflective styling going on that's in least years fashion bucket.
Peter - ouch!
I guess the reason I liked number 1 was because of the film ....
M
I like the film strip in Number One but not the slanty writing cutting across it. Maybe 1 with the text elements of 2?
No. 2, as said above though would look better with film from no. 1.
Number 1 because of the more extended width, but re-arrange the strapline as per number 2: the diagonal strapline on number 1 is a little irritating.
I"m a goer for number 2, possibly with some element of the film strip (in #1) faded behind the type?
2 does it for me
I would do: Number one, with the lettering of number two. But both of them are very nice!
Have a great weekend!
Number 2 is better, however if number on didn't have that green bar on it it would be back in the running again.
It was something I mocked up very quickly ... so not to be taken as a real logo ... but I am quite happy with it .... it does leave the text too far right and I'm aware the text isn't the clearest ...
The green bar is actually part of the forum so nothing to do wtih the logo .. but it gives it some context on the site
I quite like Mark Websters 4th offering really loving the movie reel .. its stands out so much.
Number 2 for me also. In number 1 the slanty text looks out of place, I like the idea of the film strip but again just doesnt look right.
much prefer #2
Isn't the whole film-strip thing a bit antiquated, seeing as there's a shift to DV?
Just stick in some XWings and TIE fighters - that would be awesome!
I like no.2 - clean and simple.